Graphical design component

r8 - 16 Mar 2008 - 15:12:23 - JohnWieczorekYou are here: TWiki >  DarwinCore Web > DarwinCoreDraftStandard > GlobalUniqueIdentifier

Element Description: Global Unique Identifier

A Uniform Resource Name (URN) as a unique identifier for the specimen or observation record. In the absence of a persistent global unique identifier, construct one in the form: “[InstitutionCode]:[CollectionCode]: [CatalogNumber]” Examples: 1) urn:lsid:nhm.ku.edu:Herps:32 2) “FMNH:Mammal:145732”

Open Questions:

See Open Discussion at: GBIF Circa Registries, etc.

• 5 Oct 2004 - GlobalUniqueIdentifier construction and management. (Ginzbarg GBIF Circa).

Change Log:

• 03 Aug 2005 - made minor wording changes in the description of GlobalUniqueIdentifier ( JohnWieczorek , per Ginzbarg).

Comments

Use the space below to make comments about this page. -- StephenLong - 24 Aug 2006


bubble GlobalUniqueIdentifier Posted by: Steven Ginzbarg [mailto:sginzbar@biology.as.ua.edu] Date: Tue, 05 Oct 2004, 21:08:20

The GlobalUniqueIdentifier description reads: “...In the absence of a persistent global unique identifier, ..."

We use barcodes that contain our herbarium acronym and a unique number for each sheet in the collection, e.g. UNA00012345. UNA is a registered acronym. There is no other herbarium using these letters. I can’t promise you that there isn’t a Fish collection in China also using UNA as their acronym. If I just enter UNA00012345 as the globally unique identifier it may not be globally unique. However I could enter Herbarium:UNA00012345 and that would be globally unique. More comments on GlobalUniqueIdentifier:

GlobalUniqueIdentifier: “A universal resource name for the global unique identifier for the specimen or observation record. …” Why not just: “A universal resource name for the specimen or observation record. …” If Herbarium:UNA00012345 should be entered, I would say:

  1. If the CatalogNumber is globally unique within your discipline the GlobalUniqueIdentifier should be given in the form “[Discipline]:[CatalogNumber]”. (Should this be preceded by “URN:”? by “URN:catalog:”? or just entered as [Discipline]:[CatalogNumber]? Why is “URN:” needed if the unique number is entered in a GlobalUniqueIdentifier field? What does the “catalog:” indicate?) Example: "Herbarium:UNA00012345" [Then we would need a standardized list of names of disciplines which register acronyms to choose from.]
  2. If the CatalogNumber is not globally unique with your discipline, construct one in the form "URN:catalog:[InstitutionCode]:[CollectionCode]:[CatalogNumber]".Example: "URN:catalog:UA:UNA:12345"

bubble Globally unique InstitutionCodes Posted by: Steven Ginzbarg [mailto:sginzbar@biology.as.ua.edu] Date: Thu, 07 Oct 2004, 04:33:57

From: "Mary Barkworth" Subject: RE: GlobalUniqueIdentifier Date sent: Tue, 5 Oct 2004 15:26:05 -0600

Probably the only way to guarantee a globally unique, persistent identifier is for a central registry to be started. Herbarium: herbariumcode would work. Unfortunately I did not think of it so we are USU-UTC (USU = Utah State University). I was disgusted to hear that UTC means University of Tennessee, Chattanooga to GBIF - because GBIF ignores the existence of Index Herbariorum, or perhaps it was the NBII person who was giving the demonstration of GBIF. Until and if there is a central repository (and even when there is), it may be first to register has the choice of identifier.

Mary Barkworth

-------------------------------

Mary,

In the description of CatalogNumber, DwC states “It is also recommended that each record is universally uniquely identified by the combination of InstitutionCode, CollectionCode and CatalogNumber.”

To do this the InstitutionCode must be made globally unique. The description of InstitutionCode states: “No global registry exists for institutional codes; use the code that is 'standard' in your discipline.” Our herbarium acronym is globally unique within our discipline. To make it globally unique, the discipline in which it is standard would need to be included with the acronym in the InstitutionCode.

ABCD suggests this for their SourceInstitutionID field: “… An institutional abbreviation, perhaps with indication of the standard it pertains to (e.g. IH-P for Index Herbariorum and the herbarium at the MNHN in Paris. …”

If GBIF is checking the InstitutionCodes in records of new providers and letting them know if the codes have been previously used by other providers, and providers never change their institution codes, and every institution using DwC or ABCD is providing their data to GBIF, then that would make GBIF the central registry for InstitutionCodes and maybe it doesn’t matter what is provided as the code so long as it hasn’t been used before to share data on GBIF.

How does the InstitutionCode and CollectionCode provided in the DwC table relate to the metadata provided to GBIF if at all? Our host code is UA. Resource is UAPlants. Host: University of Alabama Biodiversity and Systematics (UA) Resource: Herbarium (UNA) (UAPlants) Record Identifier: UA UNA

DwC has two fields, InstitutionCode and CollectionCode, both of which are required. InstitutionCode identifies the institution administering the collection in which the organism is cataloged. In our case that is the University of Alabama Herbarium (UNA). Some institutions such as natural history museums may administer several collections, e.g. Field Museum of Natural History may have a mammal collection as well as a plant collection. They could use FMNH as their InstitutionCode and either Mammal or Plant as their CollectionCode.

What should institutions administering only one type of collection provide as their InstitutionCode and CollectionCode? I have been providing UNA, our herbarium acronym as the CollectionCode and UA (the University of Alabama abbreviation as our InstitutionCode. However, the University of Alabama is not administering our collection, the University of Alabama Herbarium is. If we provide Herbarium_UNA or IH-UNA, as ABCD suggests for their SourceInstitutionID, what should we enter as our CollectionCode? “Plant” even though we have only plants? Repeat the InstitutionCode?


bubble
Edit | Attach | Printable | Backlinks: Web, All Webs | History: r8 < r7 < r6 < r5 < r4 | More topic actions
 
Back to TDWG Homepage TDWG Wiki > DarwinCore
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional
Copyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback